Constitution in the Headlines

Strings Attached: Religious Preschools, Public Funds, and the First Amendment

November 11, 2026

At the National Constitution Center, we value civil dialogue, which empowers students to speak about constitutional and historical topics in ways that remain civil, respectful, and reflective. As you prepare to discuss these topics in your classroom, we encourage you to establish norms such as:

  • Stay calm
  • Listen patiently
  • Listen actively
  • Don’t speak twice until everybody has spoken once

You can find more support for establishing norms and civil dialogue practices in our Civil Dialogue Toolkit.


Media Asset

National Constitution Center’s Constitution Daily Blog – Supreme Court set for arguments in another major religion case, by Mark Sherman

Big Constitutional Question

If a state pays for religious schools, can it require them to follow the same enrollment rules as every other school receiving state funding, even if those rules violate the schools’ sincerely held religious beliefs?

Headline Story

In 2020, Colorado voters approved publicly subsidized preschool for all 4-year-olds, called Universal Preschool, or UPK. Families can choose a public, private, or religious school. To receive state funding, every preschool must give every child an equal chance to enroll. Schools cannot turn away a child because of the child’s or family’s race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, housing status, income, or disability.

Two Catholic preschools near Denver, the Archdiocese of Denver, and several Catholic parents sued. Based on their sincerely held religious beliefs, the schools involved in the case wanted to make enrollment decisions based on a range of factors, including sexual orientation and gender identity. The schools argue that Colorado is excluding them because of how they practice their religion. They point to Carson v. Makin (2022), in which the Supreme Court ruled that Maine could not exclude religious schools from a program that helped families pay for private high school. Colorado counters that religious schools are welcome in the UPK (and many have enrolled in it), but they must follow the same enrollment rule as every other school. In 2023-24, 40 religious preschools took part.  Two lower courts sided with Colorado. The Supreme Court heard the case on November 3, 2026, and is expected to decide by early summer 2027.

Constitution Close-Up: The Religion Clauses

This case is about the first words of the First Amendment:

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof...”

These words are called the Religion Clauses. Break them into parts to see how each one connects to the Colorado case.

The Words

What They Mean

How They Connect to This Case

"Congress shall make no law..."

At first, this provision applied only to the national government. Because of the Fourteenth Amendment and later Supreme Court rulings, it now applies to states, too.

Colorado is a state, so its preschool program must follow the First Amendment.

“. . .respecting an establishment of religion. . .” (the Establishment Clause)

The government can’t create an official church or force people to support one. Today, the Supreme Court says public money can go to religious schools if the money is offered fairly to all schools and families choose which school their child attends.

Colorado pays for children to attend religious preschools using public funds. Consistent with current case law, this does not violate the Establishment Clause. In 2023-24, 40 religious preschools were part of UPK.

“. . .or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” (the Free Exercise Clause)

The government can’t stop people from practicing their religion. But in Employment Division v. Smith (1990), the Court said a law that applies to everyone is usually allowed, even if it makes practicing a religion more difficult. This is known as the Smith test. At the same time, the Free Exercise Clause provides strong protection against religious discrimination (Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye v. City of Hialeah), including in the context of school funding (Carson v. Makin, 2022).

The Catholic preschools argue that, as in Carson, Colorado’s rule punishes them for practicing their faith, conflicting with the Free Exercise Clause’s protection against religious discrimination. Colorado counters that its rule applies to every school, religious or not, so it passes the Smith test.

Sources: First Amendment, National Constitution Center; Interactive Constitution, The Establishment Clause and The Free Exercise Clause, National Constitution Center; “Supreme Court set for arguments in another major religion case,” by Mark Sherman, National Constitution Center; “Student Aid, Religious Education, and the First Amendment,” We the People podcast, National Constitution Center

Reflection Questions

  1. Look at the table. Which part of the First Amendment do the Catholic preschools say Colorado’s rule violates? Why does Colorado argue that its actions satisfy the requirements of this provision? In your own words, what does that part protect?
  2. Courts use earlier decisions, called precedents, to decide new cases. Find one precedent that supports the Catholic preschools and one that supports Colorado. Choose from the cases below. For each precedent you choose, explain how it connects to the Colorado case.
    1. Employment Division v. Smith (1990): The Court said a law that applies to everyone is usually allowed, even if it makes practicing a religion more difficult.
    2. Sherbert v. Verner (1963): The Court ruled that South Carolina couldn’t deny unemployment benefits to a worker who refused to work on Saturdays because of her religion.
    3. Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972): The Court ruled that Wisconsin couldn’t force Amish parents to send their children to high school, because the law seriously burdened their religious practice.
    4. Carson v. Makin (2022): The Court ruled that Maine couldn’t leave religious schools out of a program that helped families in rural areas pay for private high school. Listen to two scholars debate the case on the We the People podcast.
  3. Should a school club that receives school funding have to let every student join, or should groups have broad freedom to choose their own members? What does the Constitution have to say about this issue? How is it similar to Colorado’s preschool rule, and how is it different? Does it change your answer if the group is religious?

Extension Activities

  1. Constitution 101: How do the Religion Clauses work together? Using the Activity 10.3: Religion Clauses guide from Constitution 101 (High School), students read the Interactive Constitution essay that both scholars agreed on (the Common Interpretation) for either the Establishment Clause or the Free Exercise Clause and complete the chart. Next, as a class, read the “Aid to religious institutions” section of the Establishment Clause essay. It shows how the Court’s view on paying for religious schools changed between Everson v. Board of Education (1947) and Zelman v. Simmons-Harris (2002). Discuss: Where does the Colorado preschool case fit into the timeline? Is it primarily about the Free Exercise Clause, the Establishment Clause, or both?
  2. NCC Education Protocols: Using the National Constitution Center’s Scope of Agreement protocol, students read a short source and break its argument into smaller parts. As they read, they put a star next to each main point and underline the evidence that supports it. Then, on the Scope of Agreement graphic organizer, they list two or three points, write the evidence for each, and mark on a scale how much they agree with each point. Finally, they explain why, using the evidence they found.
    1. Example source: The paragraphs of the blog post that describe each side’s argument, beginning with “Colorado argues that the lower court rulings should be upheld.”
    2. Pairing option: Have half the class uses Frederick Gedicks’s essay “Religious Liberty Is Equal Liberty” and the other half uses Michael McConnell’s essay “Free Exercise: A Vital Protection for Diversity and Freedom,” both in the Interactive Constitution. Then have students compare how much they agree with each scholar, and why. Remember to focus on what the Constitution says, not on which policy you like best.
    3. Podcast option: Use the We the People episode, “Student Aid, Religious Education, and the First Amendment,” in which two scholars debate Carson v. Makin. Have half the class read Erwin Chemerinsky’s answer (starting at 2:56 in the transcript) and the other half read Michael McConnell’s answer (starting at 4:46 in the transcript). Then have students compare how much they agree with each scholar and why.
  3. Friend of the Court Brief: In Supreme Court cases, people and groups who are not part of the case can file an amicus curiae brief. Amicus curiae is Latin for “friend of the court.” These briefs typically offer arguments for one side of the case, often providing a different perspective. In this case, the blog post says the Trump administration and 21 states support the Catholic preschools, while 18 states support Colorado. In Carson v. Makin, both scholars on NCC’s We the People podcast, Erwin Chemerinsky and Michael McConnell, took part in amicus briefs on opposite sides. Students write their own one-page amicus curiae brief to the Justices.
    1. Choose a perspective: A Catholic family that wants to use UPK at a Catholic preschool, a family worried about being turned away from a preschool, a religious preschool that already takes part in UPK, or the state of Colorado.
    2. Introduce yourself: Who are you, and why does this case matter to you? (This section of the brief is known as the “Interests of the Amici/Amicus" section.)
    3. Make your argument: Which part of the Religion Clauses supports your side? Use the table and at least one fact from the blog post.
    4. Look ahead: How would a ruling for each side affect people like you?

Beyond the Headlines

Loading...

Explore Further

Podcast
Religious Liberty and State Funds for Preschools at the Supreme Court

Unpacking the oral arguments and exploring the constitutional issues in Saint Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy

Town Hall Video
The Holy Experiment: Religious Liberty, Pennsylvania, and the Making of America

University of Pennsylvania Professor Marci Hamilton and St. Joseph’s University Professor Emeritus Randall Miller explore how…

Blog Post
New dispute over vanity license plate language appealed to Supreme Court

How freely can states can censor what drivers wish to say on vanity license plates? The state of Virginia is asking the Supreme…

Educational Video
AP Court Case Review Featuring Caroline Fredrickson (All Levels)

In this fast-paced and fun session, Caroline Fredrickson, one of the legal scholars behind the National Constitution Center’s…