We The People

The Supreme Court Rejects the Independent State Legislature Theory

June 28, 2023

This week, the Supreme Court handed down a major decision relating to elections in America in the Moore v. Harper case. In a 6-3 ruling, the Court rejected the independent state legislature theory, finding that the Elections Clause does not give state legislatures exclusive power over elections, and upholding the power of judicial review in electoral cases, including redistricting decisions. In this episode of We the People, guests Judge Michael Luttig and Professor Evan Bernick join to break down the Moore decision – including why the Court decided to reject the independent state legislature theory; why conservative Justices Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch dissented; and what this means for the future of judicial review of election laws. Host Jeffrey Rosen moderates. 

 

Please subscribe to We the People and Live at the National Constitution Centeron Apple PodcastsStitcheror your favorite podcast app. 

This episode was produced by Lana Ulrich, Bill Pollock, Sam Desai, and Samson Mostashari. It was engineered by David Stotz. Research was provided by Lana Ulrich, Sam Desai, Samson Mostashari, Tomas Vallejo, Connor Rust, and Yara Daraiseh.   

 

Participants 

Judge Michael Luttig served on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit for 15 years, from 1991 to 2006. He is currently counselor and special advisor to the Coca-Cola Company and its board of directors, and a trustee of the National Constitution Center. He served as co-counsel for the respondents in Moore v. Harper and has written about the case in the Atlantic.  

Evan Bernick is an assistant professor of law at Northern Illinois University College of Law. He filed a brief in the case in support of the respondent in Moore v. Harper. He is the coauthor of The Original Meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment: Its Letter and Spirit (with Randy E. Barnett).  

Jeffrey Rosen is the president and CEO of the National Constitution Center, a nonpartisan nonprofit organization devoted to educating the public about the U.S. Constitution. Rosen is also a professor of law at The George Washington University Law School and a contributing editor of The Atlantic
 

Additional Resources:

Transcript

View Transcript

This transcript may not be in its final form, accuracy may vary, and it may be updated or revised in the future.

 

Stay Connected and Learn More 

Questions or comments about the show? Email us at [email protected]

Continue today’s conversation on Facebook and Twitter using @ConstitutionCtr

Sign up to receive Constitution Weekly, our email roundup of constitutional news and debate, at bit.ly/constitutionweekly

Loading...

Explore Further

Podcast
Covering the Supreme Court

How the media and the political branches influence judicial legitimacy

Town Hall Video
2025 Supreme Court Review: Key Rulings, Public Perceptions, and Constitutional Debates

The National Constitution Center and the Center on the Structural Constitution at Texas A&M University School of Law present a…

Blog Post
Supreme Court’s injunction decision a major blow to efforts to block executive policies but not the end

The U.S. Supreme Court ruling on Friday limiting federal judges’ ability to temporarily block President Trump’s executive…

Educational Video
Article III and Supreme Court Term Review Featuring Ali Velshi (All Levels)

For our final Fun Friday Session of the 2022-2023 school year, MSNBC’s Ali Velshi returns, joining National Constitution Center…

Donate

Support Programs Like These

Your generous support enables the National Constitution Center to hear the best arguments on all sides of the constitutional issues at the center of American life. As a private, nonprofit organization, we rely on support from corporations, foundations, and individuals.

Donate Today